Star Wars PocketModel is a straightforward, easy-to-learn "beer and pretzels" (or "soda and chips") game that casual gamers will find a welcome change from more complex fare like
Magic: The Gathering and
Star Wars Miniatures: Starship Battles.
Assembling the ships is a blast, and the fleets look good deployed on the dining room table. The game plays quickly, and any rules questions are easily resolved by checking out WizKids' excellent online tutorial. Games play quickly, and the flavor-text on the cards works with the impressive array of ships to lend a suitably
Star Wars-like feel to the game.
There are potential problems, though. The first is confusion surrounding the nature of the game: It looks like a miniatures game but plays like, and is billed as, a card game. Yet at the same time, the dice mechanic is something common to tabletop strategy games, and the zone movement makes it feel like a minis game. The end result can be frustrating to veterans of both genres, as card players bemoan the unpredictability of dice and miniatures fans rail against the lack of strategic movement and the need to build a deck to play.
Finally, gameplay can be too simplistic. Ship-to-ship combat, with its accompanying card play, is fun, but strikes against objectives are too easy. Since objectives can't fight back and a player only needs to destroy three objectives to win, all it takes is one or two ships with high defenses and good attack values to lay waste to an opponent's holdings and win the game. It makes for fast games but frustrating ones as well.
Maintaining a good defensive fleet, led by a capital ship of some kind, and working quickly to play objectives with high defense values can help mitigate this, but objectives are still too easy to destroy. The game cries out for objective-based defenses such as ship-disabling ion cannons, special limitations on attackers (e.g., only X-Wings can attack the Death Star) or objectives that take more than one hit to destroy.
Players new to the card or miniature game hobbies should enjoy this game, and for them the game rates a B-. But while some experienced players may enjoy the game for its casual nature, most would do well to wait an expansion or two for it to develop more depth. Ken