ON SCREEN


 
THIS ISSUE
 Star Wars: Episode I
 Trekkies


RECENT REVIEWS
 The Mummy
 Idle Hands
 Teenage Space Vampires
 eXistenZ
 Future Fantastic
 Space Truckers
 The Matrix
 Futurama
 Wing Commander
 Farscape


Request a review

Gallery

Back issues

Search

Feedback

Submissions

The Staff

Home



Suggestions

Star Wars: Episode 1 - The Phantom Menace

"The Force is strong in this one"

* Star Wars: Episode 1 - The Phantom Menace
* Rated PG
* Starring Liam Neeson, Ewan McGregor, Natalie Portman, Jake Lloyd
* Written and Directed by George Lucas
* 124 Minutes

Review by Jeff Berkwits

In an effort to compel Queen Amidala (Portman), the benevolent ruler of the small planet Naboo, to meet their outrageous demands, the Trade Federation has set up a blockade around her world. Jedi warrior Qui-Gon Jinn (Neeson) and his apprentice Obi-Wan Kenobi (McGregor) hope to find a peaceful solution to the simmering conflict, but when they board a Federation battleship, their less-than-friendly reception convinces them that negotiation is not a viable option.

Our Pick: A-

After a dramatic escape from the vessel, the duo discovers that a full-scale invasion of Naboo is imminent. They quickly travel to the royal palace via a secret route disclosed by newfound friend Jar Jar Binks (voiced by Ahmed Best), and whisk Amidala off the planet to the out-of-the-way world of Tatooine.

There the group meets the young slave Anakin Skywalker (Lloyd), who Jinn senses has the potential to become a powerful Jedi Knight. The child lends credence to those beliefs when he wins a dangerous Podrace, a victory which not only allows the political refugees to leave Tatooine but also gains the boy his freedom.

Arriving on the planet Coruscant, Amidala intends to plead her case before the Galactic Senate while Jinn hopes to receive permission to begin Skywalker's training. However, Senator Palpatine (Ian McDiarmid) has other plans, and the band soon find themselves back on Naboo, facing the evil Darth Maul (Ray Park) and fighting for the survival of nearly every creature on the planet.

A glorious adventure

Though excessive media hype has likely built up audience expectations for this movie far beyond what anyone could reasonably expect, most SF fans should find The Phantom Menace to be a monumental motion picture. George Lucas has created a truly glorious adventure, combining a familiar scenario with wondrous new worlds, vivid villains and an awe-inspiring story.

With the exception of a few relatively minor computer-generated entities, the much-ballyhooed special effects are consistently amazing, providing realistic representations of everything from huge droid invasion forces to flashy starfighters. Most of the flesh-and-blood actors are outstanding too, with McGregor marvelously matching the vocal cadence of the aged Obi-Wan and Portman echoing the fiery feistiness of her as-yet-unborn daughter Leia. Meanwhile, Neeson exhibits the quiet dignity and poise one would expect from a genuine Jedi master, while Lloyd is appropriately hopeful and innocent.

Yet the film isn't completely flawless. Some early sections are rather slow-moving, since Lucas spends considerable time detailing various political machinations and introducing new characters. And although computer-generated comedic foil Jar Jar Binks should appeal to children, most adults will likely find his prattle and personality extremely annoying.

Notwithstanding such shortcomings, Lucas has produced a movie that suitably embellishes his already highly imaginative Star Wars universe. The Phantom Menace may not be 100 percent perfect, but it's safe to say that most SF fans will find the flick favorable, fantastical and, most important of all, fun.

Folks expecting to see extended sequences with well-known characters like Yoda or C-3PO might be disappointed, although Lucas promises that they'll play much more prominent roles in future films. But those same fans will undoubtedly relish a brief appearance by the always ornery Tusken Raiders. -- Jeff

Back to the top.


Trekkies

Enthusiastic fans or raving fanatics?

* Trekkies
* Rated PG
* Featuring Denise Crosby
* Directed by Roger Nygard
* 86 Minutes



Review by Patrick Lee

Trekkies, viewers are told at the beginning of this documentary, are the only fans listed in the Oxford English Dictionary. Under the guidance of co-executive producer and actress Denise Crosby (Tasha Yar of Star Trek: The Next Generation), the audience finds out why as it boldly goes where only true believers have gone before: deep into the heart of Trek.

Our Pick: A

This often hysterically funny documentary centers on the stories of a handful of die-hard Trek fans. There's Barbara "Bobbie" Adams, the Little Rock, Ark., woman who gained worldwide fame as the Whitewater juror who wore her Starfleet uniform to court every day. There's 14-year-old Gabriel Koerner of Bakersfield, Calif., a veteran of 28 Star Trek conventions whose father's truck has a shuttlecraft-shaped camper shell. There's Denis Bourguignon, a Florida dentist whose Starbase Dental practice is housed in a Trek-themed office and who requires his staff to wear Starfleet uniforms.

And there are stories about the terminally ill fan who attributed his longer-than-expected life span to Star Trek, and whose name is commemorated by the character of Geordi La Forge. Or the invalid fan who says that her only respite from pain is the hour she spends viewing Star Trek.

As the audience follows these and other fans, the documentary makes first contact with the creators of the various Star Trek shows. They express affection for and bewilderment, discomfort and amusement at the fandom that has clearly overwhelmed them all.

The documentary touches all the bases, in and out of conventions and club meetings. There's a bit on the Klingon language school in Minnesota, and a look at why Klingons have become the most popular aliens in the Trek menagerie. A visit to a convention in Pasadena, Calif., includes a sweep through the ranks of trading tables and anecdotes about collectors--including the guy who paid $60 for John de Lancie's ("Q") germ-ridden water glass. The film takes a look at underground fan fiction (a.k.a. fanfic), in which various Trek characters are paired with others in ways that wouldn't even make it onto cable. And yes, the debate over "Trekkies" vs. "Trekkers" gets an airing.

"It's starting to become normal"

In Trekkies, director Roger Nygard and Crosby have filmed perhaps the most comprehensive, knowing and non-judgmental account of the Trek phenomenon yet. In segments alternately hilarious and sobering, the audience is introduced to Star Trek fandom in all its hideous bad taste, ennobling sentiment and touching reality.

Given that the documentary is being distributed by Paramount Studios, the owner and guardian of "the franchise," it's surprising how honest and unflinching this chronicle is. In the end, the audience actually comes a little closer to understanding why Trekkies--and perhaps any fans--come to be. The audience sees that, yes, some Trekkies are very odd, ridiculous or downright creepy. (Though, as Brent "Data" Spiner observes: "I don't think I've ever met anyone, Star Trek fan or not, who wasn't peculiar.")

Odd, as in Anne Murphy, the self-styled "Spiner femme," who bought a house with a view of her favorite star's abode. Creepy, as in the cross-dressing man who sings Klingon anthems with deep conviction. Or ridiculous, as in David and Laurel Greenstein, who dress their poodle, Tammi, in a Trek uniform. David's even a little out there for his wife, who looks on incredulously as David confesses that he would have his ears surgically pointed if only he had the money.

But the film wouldn't be so good if it just made fun of Trekkies. It also captures their heartfelt conviction, even their pain. A caller to the "Talk Trek" radio show in Sunland, Calif., thanks Crosby for her performance in a TNG episode that helped him grieve for his father. James Doohan ("Scotty") tells about the young suicidal woman he persuaded to hang on just until the next convention, then the next one, until eight years later she had recovered enough to become, yes, an engineer.

There are the platitudes about how fans love the hopeful future envisioned by Trek creator Gene Roddenberry. More convincing, though, are the testimonials by fans who confess that, in Trek, they've found the families they never had. As one says, "Nobody's estranged at a convention."

The Trek actors and producers in the film are clearly tiptoeing around the subject so as not to offend the fans. I wondered how many of the Trekkies themselves will react to their depictions. But I found it especially ironic to be watching the documentary in a Paramount Studios auditorium surrounded by industry hangers-on, many of whom laughed a little too loudly at the fans that pay for it all. -- P.L.

Back to the top.




Home

News of the Week | On Screen | Off the Shelf | Classics
Anime | Sound Space | Site of the Week | Letters | Excessive Candour


Copyright © 1998-2003, Science Fiction Weekly (TM). All rights reserved. Reproduction in any medium strictly prohibited. Maintained by scifiweekly@scifi.com.