OFF THE SHELF


 
IN THIS ISSUE
 The Tenth Planet
 The Icarus Hunt


RECENT REVIEWS
 Ancients of Days
 Souls in the Great Machine
 Shiva 3000
 Back to the Moon
 Chi
 A Signal Shattered
 Signal to Noise
 The SFWA Grand Masters, Vol. 1
 Flashforward
 The Cassini Division


Request a review

Gallery

Back issues

Search

Feedback

Submissions

The Staff

Home



Suggestions

The Tenth Planet

Humans have long feared the heavens...perhaps for good reasons

* The Tenth Planet
* By Dean Wesley Smith and Kristine Kathryn Rusch
* Del Rey
* $5.99/$6.99 Canada
* Paperback, June 1999
* ISBN 0-345-42140-X

Review by Susan Dunman

Dr. Edwin Bradshaw is an archeology professor at Oregon State University who's about to turn 60. He spends his time supervising dig sites along the Oregon coast and avoiding a research controversy that discredited his professional reputation 20 years earlier. His current excavations reveal nothing extraordinary, so he is shocked to receive a request for additional information about his site from Dr. Leo Cross, the world's preeminent archeological historian.

Our Pick: B

Clark wants to know if there is a thin layer of black residue covering the Oregon site at any level. Bradshaw finds a black ring one-eighth inch wide at the 4,000-year-old depth level and eventually learns Cross has found more than 50 archeological sites containing black rings composed of magnetite. Even more perplexing is the appearance of the rings at depths ranging from 16,000 to 2,000 years old. Cross explains that many ancient cultures refer to a "Time of Blackness" and these records correlate to the dates of the rings. But most disturbing is the conclusion made by Cross that the mysterious black rings appear every 2,006 years...and it's time for another occurrence.

Meanwhile, an international space buoy orbiting Uranus unexpectedly stops transmitting. A thorough analysis of the data shows that the buoy was instantly drained of all power--an anomaly that should not be possible. When telescopes are trained toward Uranus, scientists are amazed to find a black, unidentifiable mass headed toward the inner solar system. Calculations indicate the object orbits the sun, it's twice the size of the moon, and it passes near Earth every 2,006 years.

240 days until arrival

It won't take long for readers to figure out where this story is going, but fortunately, a little premonition seems to help the plot. In fact, it's part of the fun to see if these authors will take the expected routes with their disaster tale or veer off into uncharted territory. Although it may sound similar, this is not another Independence Day. As the book cover suggests, there are alien forces at work, but they do not approach Earth with evil intent. It is the unexpected results of their seemingly harmless activity (at least from their point of view) that provide the intrigue and suspense.

The story is told from multiple viewpoints, giving an immediacy and urgency to the narration. The authors create believable characters that readers can cheer as they try to solve an ancient riddle. There are also enough tidbits about archeology and astronomy to give the book a feeling of authority. The first chapter begins with the heading "240 Days Until Arrival." Each following chapter continues the countdown, building up tension in a way that really keeps the pages turning.

Those who like their stories wrapped up in one volume may wish to steer away from this adventure, as it's the first of a three-part offering. The authors have previously written for series such as The X-Men and Star Wars, and this book has much the same feel as one of those ongoing sagas. Also, readers seeking profound insights should look elsewhere. On the other hand, this quick read can't be beat for those who need a break during a bad TV night.

The threat of world cataclysm may seem like a worn-out topic, but this book makes the subject fresh and inviting. -- Susan

Back to the top.


The Icarus Hunt

A freighter pilot and his ship become fugitives sought throughout the inhabited universe

* The Icarus Hunt
* By Timothy Zahn
* Bantam Spectra
* $23.95/$34.95 Canada
* Hardcover, Aug. 1999
* ISBN 0-553-10702-X

Review by Clinton Lawrence

In Timothy Zahn's new novel The Icarus Hunt, a rich industrialist clandestinely hires Jordan McKell to pilot a freighter carrying a secret cargo from the planet Meima to Earth. McKell takes the assignment and leaves it up to his alien partner to fulfill their current obligations to their usual employer, an underground organization. Unfortunately, on his way to meet the crew of his new ship, the Icarus, McKell is detained by authorities. The industrialist, Arno Cameron, is wanted for murder, and the authorities have been tipped that McKell met with him.

Our Pick: B-

McKell is quickly released, but Cameron fails to meet the crew at the ship as expected. Instead, they find a letter and their bonuses, with instructions to proceed without him. But on the first hyperspace jump the ship malfunctions, and McKell suspects sabotage. Then, as repairs are being made, someone murders one of the crew members. Faced with a crew he can't trust, McKell decides to divert the Icarus from its planned course to pick up his old partner as a replacement. Unfortunately, he quickly learns that the Icarus is a wanted ship.

Another species, known as the Patth, dominate interstellar trade because of their vastly superior stardrive. Suspicions are arising that the secret cargo carried by the Icarus is an alien stardrive, uncovered by archaeologists on Meima, even better than the Patth's. The Patth have the political influence to coerce other governments to help them find the Icarus and prevent the cargo from reaching human space. Worse, one of the crew members has a deadly disease contracted on a visit to an illegal planet, and McKell must find a black-market source at every stop in order to buy the drug that can treat the disease. The only solution is to create a false identity for the Icarus, and try to select planets that minimize the risks.

A competent space opera

The Icarus Hunt is a competent, enjoyable space opera, but it lacks the depth to achieve a place alongside the best current science fiction novels. Nonetheless, Zahn creates an interesting mystery with a conclusion that's both consistent with the previous events and concealed well enough until the end to be satisfying. While the characterizations don't go beyond the basic needs of the narrative, they're adequate for the story being told. McKell and his partner, Ixil, are enjoyably resourceful for reasons that are surprising when revealed at the end. And the chase itself, across numerous backwater worlds in Zahn's inhabited universe, is suspenseful, especially when superimposed upon the mysterious occurrences aboard the Icarus.

Unfortunately, Zahn's universe doesn't seem to come alive as much as it should. It's a potentially fascinating world, filled with alien species that are forced to coexist, but the story and structure of The Icarus Hunt don't allow Zahn the opportunity to fully explore some of the more interesting aspects. What he does reveal suggests the possibility that it's a universe where Zahn could find many more novels without repeating himself, and which could be much better than The Icarus Hunt.

Still, The Icarus Hunt is a reasonably good novel that should entertain many readers. It's not without its flaws, but Zahn overcomes most of them by controlling the pacing so that the story unfolds naturally, and by making sure the plot isn't predictable. Best of all, while Zahn conceals much until the end, he never cheats his readers in this novel. It's a good book for those who read science fiction primarily for entertainment rather than intellectual or literary value.

I think The Icarus Hunt would make a pretty good SF movie. It's got enough intrigue and action to translate well to the screen, without insulting the intelligence of its audience. -- Clint

Back to the top.




Home

News of the Week | On Screen | Off the Shelf | Classics
Anime | Sound Space | Site of the Week | Letters | Excessive Candour


Copyright © 1998-2003, Science Fiction Weekly (TM). All rights reserved. Reproduction in any medium strictly prohibited. Maintained by scifiweekly@scifi.com.