CLASSIC SCI-FI


RECENT REVIEWS
 House on Haunted Hill
 Space Ace
 The Beastmaster
 This Island Earth
 The Skylark of Space
 Slaughterhouse-Five
 Barbarella
 The Dispossessed
 Island of Lost Souls
 Space Patrol


Request a review

Gallery

Back issues

Search

Feedback

Submissions

The Staff

Home



Suggestions


The War Against the Rull

Shape-shifters and telepaths and bug-eyed monsters, oh my!

* The War Against the Rull
* By A.E. Van Vogt
* Orb
* $13.95/$19.95 Canada
* Trade Paperback, Aug. 1999
* ISBN 0-312-85239-8

Review by Nalo Hopkinson

The War Against the Rull is a novel that consists of seven short stories, six of which originally appeared in Astounding Science Fiction Magazine between 1940 and 1950. The seventh and final story was originally published in 1978, in the collection Pendulum.

Our Pick: B-

The stories trace humanity's battle with the Rull, a belligerent race of alien shapechangers who have the ability to manipulate light. In the first section, scientist Trevor Jamieson is trapped on the planet Eristan II with an ezwal, a huge, telepathic, six-limbed creature from Carson's Planet. Jamieson has discovered that ezwals are intelligent, a fact they've been trying to hide from humans in order to prevent their world from being colonized. The ezwal is determined to kill Jamieson to protect the secret. The stakes are raised when a Rull warship lands nearby, and the ezwal decides to give Jamieson to them. Instead, Jamieson ends up rescuing the ezwal and returning him to Carson's Planet. But the human military council on Carson's is not willing to start treating the ezwals as sentient beings. They concoct a plan to kill Jamieson to prevent him from spreading his message. Instead he turns the tables again and saves the life of the woman chosen for the job.

On Earth, shape-changing Rulls, disguised as humans, have infiltrated the military. The military creates increasingly sophisticated methods of detecting Rulls, but security breaches continue. Humanity is being overrun. Jamieson sets about trying to convince the military machine that the ezwals' telepathy will be useful in the battle against the Rull. There's only one problem, which Jamieson is keeping quiet about: ezwals cannot read the minds of Rull beings. While Jamieson is battling the bureacracy, Rulls capture his nine-year-old son. Does Jamieson have a plan to save his child, much less the whole human race?

"Ah, careless, rapturous van Vogt!" --Barry N. Malzberg

The War Against the Rull clearly displays its pulp SF roots. Energetic and inventive (though not particularly grounded in science), it's a microcosm of the attitudes of the American '50s. The jungle of Eristan II is "repellent" and "treacherous," and fauna are "monstrous things...mewing and slavering in feral desire." Because the ezwals are unwilling to be subject to a human agenda, Jamieson judges them too primitive for true intelligence. They and other races are confined without their permission and treated as clever helpmeets. A woman who acts decisively is said to be displaying an "unfeminine firmness." The "wormlike" bodies of the Rull are described with revulsion. It's a worldview that's at base xenophobic and misogynist.

But a good artist matures; The War Against the Rull illustrates that. Because it spans 38 years, it's possible--and fascinating--to see attitude shifts. Even in the earlier stories, women are active in positions of authority, which was somewhat revolutionary for fiction of the '40s. Jamieson treats ezwals much more like equals by the second encounter with them. By the middle of the novel, the Rulls, though enemies, are described as brave fighters.

As is inevitable though, Van Vogt's writing continued to mirror his society; the final story, set on a university campus in the '70s, describes a female commune member whose male "leader" has instructed her to have sex with their physics professor so that the whole commune gets A's. The bizarre notion of what a commune is was perhaps colored by media hype about "free love" and by the Charles Manson gang, whose killings were still fresh in everyone's minds at the time of the story's publication.

This Orb edition of Rull is the first time that all the Rull stories have been collected in one volume. It's a valuable artifact by a prolific writer who challenged himself continually, and who also wrote Slan, the classic SF novel about racial hatred.

Locus Magazine reports that the Canadian Van Vogt has recently been institutionalized with Alzheimer's disease. It was poignant for me to be writing in the past tense about the works of a living author who will probably not write again. -- Nalo


Home

News of the Week | On Screen | Off the Shelf | Classics
Anime | Sound Space | Site of the Week | Letters | Excessive Candour


Copyright © 1998-2003, Science Fiction Weekly (TM). All rights reserved. Reproduction in any medium strictly prohibited. Maintained by scifiweekly@scifi.com.