COOL SCI-FI STUFF


Cool Stuff
RECENT REVIEWS
 LEGO Mindstorms Droid Developer Kit
 The Twilight Zone Companion, Second Edition
 Phantom Quest: The Search for Extraterrestrials
 Artemis Magazine
 Greetings, Carbon-Based Bipeds!
 Japan's Favorite Mon-Star
 Ghostbusters DVD
 SCI FI Channel's Seeing Ear Theatre - Volume 3
 Star Wars: Episode I - Insider's Guide
 Flight of the Bumble Bee


Request a review

Gallery

Back issues

Search

Feedback

Submissions

The Staff

Home



Suggestions


Hayao Miyazaki: Master of Japanese Animation

To sum up: one director, extra-cool

* Hayao Miyazaki: Master of Japanese Animation
* By Helen McCarthy
* Stone Bridge Press
* $18.95
* Trade paperback, Oct. 1999
* ISBN: 1-880656-41-8

Review by Tasha Robinson

The automatic impulse upon picking up Hayao Miyazaki: Master of Japanese Animation is to flip to the color inset with the eight pages of stills from Miyazaki's movies. The photos are printed on quality glossy paper that brings out the rich, deep palette of key shots from Laputa: Castle in the Sky and the Miyazaki-written Whisper of the Heart. The immediate temptation is to cut these pages out and put them on the wall.

Our Pick: b-

His images are no less compelling in motion. Miyazaki's animated movies, including the touching, tender My Neighbor Totoro, the complex and emotional Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind, and the visual extravaganza Princess Mononoke, arouse deep emotion in serious animation buffs. Until recently, his films were hard to find in the United States outside of "fansub" rings and the occasional film festival. But Disney's purchase of the U.S. release rights to much of Miyazaki's studio's theatrical output seems to be changing that. Kiki's Delivery Service came out on video in 1998 to rave reviews and strong sales. Mononoke is currently in theaters. Castle in the Sky is reportedly due on video next year.

Amid the new wave of U.S. enthusiasm over a director Japan has known for decades as a national treasure, Helen McCarthy's book provides a lot more than some fantastic color shots. It's an essential guide to Miyazaki's work. It provides a brisk, simple history of the man's career, from his "war baby" childhood to an unnamed future film. A selective bibliography details Miyazaki's works, including the various Studio Ghibli anime releases and Miyazaki's manga. For each of the films Miyazaki actually directed, McCarthy provides a history, a list of origins and inspirations, a very detailed plot summary, brief bios on the major characters, and a few pages of thematic and critical analysis. The book winds up with a chapter on "the Miyazaki machine," mostly about Ghibli's merchandising and spinoff deals.

Clean and clear, but quite comprehensive

Hayao Miyazaki: Master of Japanese Animation is mostly a useful reference book for new fans who have seen one of the few U.S. releases and want to know more about the director whose vision shaped them. For hardcore Miyazaki fans, a great deal of this information will be redundant--the plot summaries, for instance, are painstakingly thorough and somewhat repetitive with the character summaries. Put together, they might substitute for a first viewing of the film, if it's currently unavailable, or help a fan walk through one of the Japanese-only copies circulating between local otaku, but for anyone who's seen the films, it's all so much padding.

The critical analysis, while neither shallow nor uninformed, tends to skid quickly from one aspect of a film to the next. McCarthy's insights are often illuminating, and her observations apt, but she keeps the book short by making her points briefly and moving on. This can be frustrating when dealing with works as rich and tangled as Miyazaki's. The book has no index and no interview; McCarthy has interviewed the director, but scatters his commentary throughout the book in small nuggets.

But Master shines in the clear, crisp history and the "Origins" sections for each movie, which provide everything from production trivia to Miyazaki's own analysis of his themes. The entire book is light, breezy, compelling to read and easy to understand. It's enthusiastic but not entirely uncritical, informative but not bogged down in minutiae. Black-and-white stills and photos are included on virtually every other page. McCarthy has a good sense for the themes and tones that make Miyazaki's work so compelling, and her analysis is usually right on target. While it might be more satisfying for serious fans to see her put together a denser, more involved work, this book at least is a polished, enjoyable Miyazaki introduction, with enough intriguing detail to keep the addicts entertained.

The six-page insert on the process of theatrical animation was interesting and useful, but for goodness' sake, whose idea was it to wedge it in the middle of the history section, splitting a thought in mid-sentence before and behind it, instead of putting it at the beginning or end of the section? -- Tasha


Home

News of the Week | On Screen | Off the Shelf | Classics
Cool Stuff | Games | Site of the Week | Letters | Interview


Copyright © 1998-2006, Science Fiction Weekly (TM). All rights reserved. Reproduction in any medium strictly prohibited. Maintained by scifiweekly@scifi.com.