ON SCREEN


 
THIS ISSUE
 Ultimate Trek: Star Trek's Greatest Moments
 The World Is Not Enough
 Toy Story 2


RECENT REVIEWS
 End of Days
 Hercules: The Legendary Journeys
 Sleepy Hollow
 Dogma
 Y2K
 Being John Malkovich
 Pokemon: The First Movie--Mewtwo Strikes Back
 Princess Mononoke
 Poltergeist: The Legacy -- "The Beast Within"
 The Magical Legend of the Leprechauns


Request a review

Gallery

Back issues

Search

Feedback

Submissions

The Staff

Home



Suggestions


Ultimate Trek: Star Trek's Greatest Moments

Comedy shtick and media bites

* Ultimate Trek: Star Trek's Greatest Moments
* Starring Jason Alexander, Jay Johnston, Dana Gould
* Written by Chris Henchy and Robert Cohen
* Produced and directed by Michael Stevens
* UPN
* Wednesday, Dec. 1
* 8 p.m. ET/PT

Review by John Platt

Going where no one has dared go before, UPN combines Star Trek comedy routines with a compressed history of the series in Ultimate Trek: Star Trek's Greatest Moments. Jason Alexander, of Seinfeld fame, takes on the role of Captain James T. Kirk travelling back in time to 1999 with Mr. Spock (Johnston) and Dr. McCoy (Gould) at his side. Their mission? To prevent the Y2K bug from interrupting the broadcast of Star Trek.

Our Pick: C-

To help themselves in their millennial mission, this mock Enterprise crew repeatedly accesses the ship's computer to display episode clips from the various Star Trek TV series and films. These clips cover such diverse topics as Ultimate Villains, Ultimate Beauties, Best One-Liners, and so on. This is all delivered in a glib, tongue-in-cheek manner from the fanboy cast to what they assume will be a mostly Trekker audience.

Along the way, Kirk and da boyz must deal with a bevy of beautiful lingerie models, an obnoxious NBC executive, and a Paramount security guard as they work their way to the bridge of Voyager to correct the Y2K flaw. But the skits are, of course, merely an excuse to show brief snippets of Star Trek footage.

At each commercial break, viewers are quizzed on Star Trek trivia. Also during the program, viewers are encouraged to log on to startrek.com and vote for the Ultimate Star Trek Episode of All Time from the four choices offered at the beginning of the show. This Ultimate Episode, based on viewers' votes, will be revealed at the end of the program.

Beam me out of here, Scotty!

As soon as the producers of this special decided to name it Ultimate Trek: Star Trek's Greatest Moments, they should have realized they were asking for trouble. With more than 30 years of Star Trek history, any attempt to cram all the best moments into one hour seems doomed to failure. And, for the most part, that's what has happened here.

Star Trek fans--Trekkers, Trekkies or whatever they prefer to be called--hold this subject dear to their hearts, and certainly know more about it than this special's production team. Every clip montage presented in Ultimate Trek is announced with a superlative--the Ultimate this, the Best that--and the debate among Trekkers will begin almost immediately. How can a list of Ultimate Trek Villains, which so obviously includes the Borg and Kahn, leave out any mention of the Gorn, Harry Mudd, Lord Garth, the god Apollo, or any number of others? How can a clip montage of Ultimate Trek Beauties forget to include Vina from "The Menagerie," and even Seven of Nine? Who put these lists together?

Another problem with Ultimate Trek is the comedy skits. Although Alexander, Johnston and Gould do fine impersonations of Kirk, Spock and Bones, the jokes are only somewhat amusing; the silly plot is not particularly interesting, and the production looks cheap. The whole idea of tying Star Trek's Supposedly Greatest Moments together by a series of cheap comedy skits is one of those TV producer decisions that ranks right up there with The Star Wars Christmas Special. Just what in the galaxy were these people thinking?

But perhaps the most disappointing aspect of Ultimate Trek is its inability to convey any real sense of Star Trek to non-fans. The clip montages are so brief and out of context that only fans will have any idea what's going on. This program teaches nothing and makes no converts. In fact, the silly comedy skits may have the adverse effect of turning intelligent non-Trekkers away from the series, believing Trek to be just a bunch of camp silliness--and with a series as important to science fiction as Star Trek, that's a real shame.

Even with all these flaws, hard-core Trekkers may enjoy debating the lists with their friends, and they might find a few chuckles amid the many groans.

I didn't hate this show, I was just very disappointed. With a title like Ultimate Trek: Star Trek's Greatest Moments, I had hoped for something with more substance and impact. After all, I'm proud to be a Trekker! -- J.P.

Back to the top.


The World Is Not Enough

Detonated, not stirred

* The World Is Not Enough
* Rated PG-13
* Starring Pierce Brosnan, Sophie Marceau, Denise Richards, Judi Dench, John Cleese
* Written by Neal Purvis (story) and Robert Wade
* Directed by Michael Apted
* United Artists
* 127 Minutes

Review by A.M. Dellamonica

James Bond (Brosnan) isn't quite the iron man of his younger days. When he rescues a briefcase full of money on behalf of an old friend of M's, the case explodes, killing the friend and wounding Bond's shoulder and--more importantly--his pride. As the rest of M.I. 6 gears up to find the parties responsible, 007 is sidelined by his injury, but still intent on solving the case himself.

Our Pick: A-

His investigation leads him to Elektra King (Marceau), the slain man's daughter. Kidnapped several years ago by a deranged terrorist, the young heiress has now taken over the reins of her father's company. She is determined to complete work on his oil pipeline, even though the project's enemies are numerous: locals displaced by the line, competing oil projects, and even several Middle Eastern governments. Convinced that Elektra's life is in danger, Bond charms his way back onto the active duty roster and rushes to the rescue.

His instincts are correct, and soon the pair are running for their lives. What's more, the killers have been planted inside the King corporate empire. And the assassins' plans extend far beyond murdering one young and beautiful CEO. Soon the still-injured Bond finds himself fighting not only to save Elektra, but to prevent a nuclear meltdown.

An exhilarating one-man show

The World Is Not Enough is the best Bond film in years. Fast-paced and exciting, it has a competent script and some very funny moments. Brosnan carries off Bond with grace and humor, switching easily from cool sophistication to hard-hitting heroics. Most of the supporting players give top-notch performances. Robbie Coltrane is especially delightful as a caviar-loving Russian gangster.

Tragically, the wonderful casting is barely exploited. The focus of a Bond film is 007 himself, and the characters who get the most play are the villain he fights and the women he seduces. It is unfortunate, then, that Marceau as Elektra and Robert Carlyle as the dying terrorist, Renard, are among the least vibrant characters. Perhaps the two simply cannot shine in a movie featuring actors as seasoned and appealing as Judi Dench and John Cleese. Viewers will find, though, that this weakness is covered by the non-stop plunging thrill ride of the film.

Bond fans who particularly enjoy the clever gadgets created by Q may be slightly disappointed by this movie. Bond's car barely sees action, and though he uses some smaller gizmos, they never bail him out of trouble at a critical moment. As compensation, Renard's forces are well equipped with a plethora of deadly and unusual toys.

The last Bond movie of this century, The World Is Not Enough is bipolar in its approach to sexual politics. Brosnan indulges in the usual smarmy leering, double entendre, and seduction. However, the film tries to placate '90s moviegoers by attempting to empower the movie's requisite scantily clad women. Elektra is an industrial magnate; Christmas Jones (Richards), a nuclear physicist. Feminist viewers may wonder why the filmmakers bothered, noting that Elektra merely inherited Daddy's company and that Christmas never actually disarms a nuclear bomb, despite multiple opportunities.

With these caveats in mind, buckle up for lots of excitement and laughs.

This was tons of fun. The suspense worked beautifully and the title credits were gorgeous. It felt like one of the early Connery films. -- A.M.

Back to the top.


Toy Story 2

Woody's been kidnapped--this looks like a job for Buzz Lightyear!

* Toy Story 2
* Rated G
* Starring Tom Hanks, Tim Allen, Joan Cusack, Wayne Knight, Kelsey Grammer
* Directed by John Lasseter
* Written by Andrew Stanton, Rita Hsiao, Doug Chamberlin, Chris Webb
* Disney
* 95 Minutes

Review by Patrick Lee

Woody the toy cowboy (Hanks) is looking forward to time away with his beloved Andy at cowboy camp. But a mishap leaves Woody with a torn seam, and he's relegated to Andy's bedroom shelf--the last step for toys before the 25-cent yard sale box.

Our Pick: A

"I'm sorry, honey," Andy's mom says. "But you know toys don't last forever."

Woody is chilled by the idea that his idyllic life with Andy and the other toys might someday end. It spurs him to save another toy--Wheezy, the broken penguin--from yard sale oblivion. But Woody doesn't make it back into the house.

Instead, he's found by a toy collector--Al (Knight), the money-grubbing proprietor of Al's Toy Barn. Al recognizes that Woody is a rare collectible, part of a line of toys created around the 1950s television show Woody's Roundup. Andy's mom won't sell Woody to Al because she knows how precious he is to her son, so Al steals Woody while the other toys watch.

Buzz Lightyear (Allen), rallies the other toys to mount a rescue mission. "Woody once risked his life to save me," Buzz tells the others. "I wouldn't be much of a friend if I didn't do the same." With Slinky Dog, Mr. Potato Head, Rex and Hamm the piggy bank, he sets out into a world that's all too dangerous for little toys. And this time the intrepid playthings have much farther to go than just next door.

"I wouldn't miss it."

Toy Story 2, from Walt Disney and Pixar Animation Studios, is a worthy sequel to the 1995 hit Toy Story. It shares with that film dazzling animation, terrific voice acting and a charming and occasionally hilarious script. But this film is deeper and more heartfelt than the first, with a poignant theme about the joy and sorrow of being loved.

The film's computer animation is state-of-the-art. The characters, especially Woody and Buzz, are fully realized. And there are sequences that will knock an audience's socks off, particularly the opening scene featuring Buzz, and later the toys' attempt to cross a busy street. There are also some impressive, more subtle, effects, from rustling leaves to cheese-dust-covered fingers on one character.

The script is clever and knowing--it includes sly allusions to Jurassic Park: The Lost World and Star Wars. And it works nostalgia to create Woody's Roundup, a Howdy Doody-like TV show that was the wellspring of Woody's family. It's a nice conceit to play on the current rage for toy collectibles. "Look at us! We're a complete set!" Woody exclaims at one point.

The film's music is also a pleasure, with a score by Randy Newman and songs performed by Sarah McLachlan and Riders in the Sky. Newman's signature "You've Got a Friend in Me" from the first movie is featured.

Really the only complaint is Toy Story 2's blatant use of product placements, particularly for Mattel toys.

It would be a mistake to think of the Toy Story movies as simply kid stuff. Though they are ideal for young children, they also hold pleasures for those of us whose toys now come with vehicle registrations and remote controls. -- P.L.

Back to the top.





Home

News of the Week | On Screen | Off the Shelf | Games | Anime
Sound Space | Site of the Week | Letters | Excessive Candour


Copyright © 1998-2003, Science Fiction Weekly (TM). All rights reserved. Reproduction in any medium strictly prohibited. Maintained by scifiweekly@scifi.com.