OFF THE SHELF


 
IN THIS ISSUE
 Code of Conduct
 All of an Instant


RECENT REVIEWS
 Manifold: Time
 The Naked God
 The Martian Race
 Precursor
 Timeline
 Double Contact
 Miracle and Other Christmas Stories
 Typhon's Children
 Starfire
 Field of Dishonor


Request a review

Gallery

Back issues

Search

Feedback

Submissions

The Staff

Home



Suggestions


Code of Conduct

Will a high-society murder spell doom for a lonely fugitive?

* Code of Conduct
* By Kristine Smith
* Avon EOS
* $5.99/$7.99 Canada
* Paperback, Dec. 1999
* ISBN 0-380-80783-1

Review by A.M. Dellamonica

Captain Jani Kilian has been presumed dead for 18 years, ever since a bombing on the alien world of the idomeni. A fugitive since the explosion, she is haunted by memories of lost comrades, lethal decisions, and the injuries that nearly killed her. Extensive surgery saved Jani's life, and now, with a new face, she ekes out an existence on the fringes of human society, processing documents on backwater colony worlds. Avoiding entanglements with would-be friends, she moves on at the slightest hint of discovery, and with good reason. If she is caught, she will certainly be executed, either by the idomeni or by her own people.

Our Pick: B

But the appearance of an old lover brings Jani's flight to a pause. The lover, Evan Van Reuter, has risen to a powerful political position in the Commonwealth--but he is headed for a fall. Hounded by political opponents and the media, he suspects his wife's recent death was murder rather than an accident, and he begs Jani to investigate.

Her reluctant acceptance plunges Jani into a world of wealth, intrigue, and tragedy. Digging into Evan's past, she finds fodder for scandal, and motives aplenty for homicide. When all three Van Reuter children died in a boating accident, their parents fell apart. Evan descended into alcoholism; his wife sabotaged his career and gave incriminating evidence to his enemies. The trail leads Jani back to the events of her own dark past--the diplomatic mission to the idomeni which went so badly awry.

Unfortunately, Jani's health is failing. Chances are good that she will die before she finds the answers that she and Evan need.

Dark and suspenseful

Code of Conduct is a very particular type of book, and one that will be familiar to most readers. Decades-old mysteries and lone, haunted soldiers are staples of many genres, not just SF, and fortunately author Kristine Smith shows herself to be talented and thoughtful in her approach to this otherwise old ground. She works hard to avoid clichés. Jani seeks closure for the old and bloody events of her life, but her state of crisis is a quiet one, tempered by time. This is utterly appropriate--she is an emotionally sturdy character, and it would be unrealistic if her psychic wounds still visibly bled.

Unfortunately, characters are usually more dramatic when they are closer to the edge. Smith's realistic and intelligent approach means that Jani is in many ways simply dull. Readers may expect more depth and resourcefulness from a woman in her forties, who has survived an alien civil war, an attempt on her life, drastic surgery and 18 years of pursuit by law enforcement. Novels featuring older women as protagonists are rare things, generally to be treasured. Somehow, though, Jani fails to shine, fails to make the most of her age and experience and fails to provide a thoroughly admirable heroine.

The intense interplay of human-idomeni relations is rich and well realized in Code of Conduct. Despite a sparseness of information about the idomeni and the long-ago civil war, richness and complexity pervade Evan's household. This tantalizing culture is conveyed in tiny glimpses: the narrative rarely lingers on the details of the colonies' history, on the current state of human technology, or even on the society of Smith's intriguing aliens. When combined with the double fistful of loose ends at the novel's close, this sense of unearthed riches will definitely leave readers wanting more.

Fun and suspenseful, but it won't feel finished until another whole book (at least!) comes out chronicling Jani's adventures. -- Alyx

Back to the top.


All of an Instant

A predatory war for control of all time

* All of an Instant
* By Richard Garfinkle
* Tor Books
* $24.95/$35.95 Canada
* Hardcover, Nov. 1999
* ISBN 0-312-86617-8

Review by Joe Monti

All of an Instant, Richard Garfinkle's second novel, deals with the consequences of humanity's discovery of a temporal existence amidst a time-ocean dubbed the Instant, and the wars that rage over its control.

Our Pick: B

The novel opens with a man, Dhiritirashta, who accidentally discovers and subsequently frees himself from the constraints of temporal existence on Earth, which he calls the Flux, and passes into an atemporal existence amidst an ocean of time, the Instant. Once in the Instant, Dhiritirashta finds that he can control and change events in the Flux by directing the waves of the ocean to achieve his desires. He then begins to alter reality to suit his vision of utopia.

Below, in the Flux, stories of a temporal god incite rebellion, and three men discover how to enter into the Instant in order to liberate the Earth. This triumvirate defeats Dhiritirashta, and while they are in the process of molding the world to their vision, another set of liberators comes forth. They eventually become victorious, and in turn are defeated by other factions, each with its own view of utopia.

With every conflict, history is vastly altered below in the Flux. Nevertheless, factions constantly arrive from the Flux, until nearly 50,000 tribal warriors exist within the Instant--all vying for control. Howeverm three groups stand out from the rest: The Ghosts; the Drums; and the Instant's only army. Within these three groups are three remarkable individuals, Nir, the War Chief of the Ghosts, Kookatchi the thief (a Drum), and Quillithe', the leader of the Instant's only army and a master strategist. These three will come to discover the true nature of the Instant and either save humanity from the whirlpool of temporal chaos that rages below in the Flux or destroy it all.

The fourth dimension viewed in two

The idea of time warriors battling for control of history is not new, but Garfinkle's execution of it is extensively thought out. The idea of an atemporal existence, manifested as an ocean, and the physical and metaphysical consequences of this metaphor, drive the plot. The puzzling out of existence in a physical manifestation of time will fascinate readers, especially as seen from the perspective of Kookatchi the thief, whose life span in the Instant is only a minute long! As Kookatchi's life recycles, minute by minute, his understanding of the ocean's true beauty borders on the profound. But Garfinkle's lack of substantial characterization can tend to expel the reader from the moment.

And while Garfinkle's prose is suitable for the philosophical pondering of time, it lacks the emotion needed to convey the passions of Nir, Kookatchi, and Quillithe'. Instead, their motivations are couched in philosophy. Characteristic of this are the Ghosts, a tribe dedicated to preserving the life of the first Homo sapien--The Great Mother--and the first 200 years of humanity from change. They show no human desire or thought and exist simply as warriors. They were once humans, yet they, like all the background inhabitants of the Instant, are portrayed as two-dimensional, rapacious, would-be temporal emperors. Which is a disappointment when compared to the wonders of the theoretical Instant. Yet despite these problems, Garfinkle has created an engaging exploration of time expressed in an epic tale.

While I found this book to be flawed, the flaws, whether they are the weak characterization or the pervasive maleness of the work, are only so evident because of the reflective joys I gained from the intricate game played out on the pages of this novel. -- Joe

Back to the top.




Home

News of the Week | On Screen | Off the Shelf | Classics
Cool Stuff | Games | Site of the Week | Letters | Interview


Copyright © 1998-2006, Science Fiction Weekly (TM). All rights reserved. Reproduction in any medium strictly prohibited. Maintained by scifiweekly@scifi.com.