COOL SCI-FI STUFF


Cool Stuff
RECENT REVIEWS
 Star Wars: Episode I Picture Plus Image Camera
 Amazons of Cydonia
 The Klingon Hamlet
 Spock vs. Q
 Stephen King's F13
 The Book of End Times: Grappling With the Millennium
 Science Fiction of the 20th Century: An Illustrated History
 Mars 2112 Restaurant and Bar
 Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Companion
 Saucer Wisdom


Request a review

Gallery

Back issues

Search

Feedback

Submissions

The Staff

Home



Suggestions


Wyrd Sisters

Semi-Shakespearean semi-silliness

* Wyrd Sisters
* Starring Christopher Lee, Jane Horrocks, June Whitfield and Eleanor Bron
* Directed by Jean Flynn
* Written by Jimmy Hibbert
* Acorn Media/Cosgrove Hall Films
* 147 Minutes
* MSRP $39.95 VHS or DVD

Review by Tasha Robinson

Terry Pratchett's sixth Discworld novel, Wyrd Sisters, takes its basic framework from Shakespeare's Macbeth (with a little Hamlet thrown in), but in this scenario the witches are the central characters, and the story is as much about their conflicting styles as about the murdering usurper and the revenge-seeking ghost-king. This British animated adaptation, recently made available in the U.S., stars Lee in a minor role as the incarnation of Death, and Absolutely Fabulous veterans Horrocks and Whitfield as witches Magrat and Nanny Ogg.

Our Pick: B

In the small mountain kingdom of Lancre, King Verence is murdered by the scheming Duke and Duchess Felmet, who take over as rulers and start oppressing the people and burning their homes. Verence used to do the same sort of thing, but he was generally more polite about it--he tended to let the residents out first. Normally, the witches of Lancre--formidable, grim Granny Weatherwax, crude but motherly Nanny Ogg and young, awkward Magrat--avoid politics, but it's difficult to stay uninvolved when a dying servant drops an infant prince into their arms just before Duke Felmet's soldiers arrive to finish off what their master started. It's also hard to ignore the fact that Felmet is dangerously insane, and his presence on the throne is awakening powers best left asleep.

Granny Weatherwax doesn't approve of using magic to change the world around her in frivolous ways, but she has a strong sense of truth, justice and her own rights, which include terrified respect from everyone in Lancre. But the bumbling court fool shows Felmet how words can change reality, and Felmet decides to rewrite history. When Granny and her fractious coven learn of Felmet's scheme to cast himself as the heroic savior of Lancre and the witches as scheming, meddling hags, they decide that if they're going to meddle, they might as well do it right.

Fun times and fan service

Cosgrove-Hall's 1996 Wyrd Sisters TV miniseries was a relatively low-budget production, but the company's dedication to Pratchett's original work shows through in every scene. Hibbert's script follows the book in minute, line-by-line detail, incorporating Pratchett's dialogue and adapting his narration into dialogue where necessary to explain a scene (or, in some cases, where Hibbert was apparently unable to pass up one of Pratchett's puns or twists of phrase). The cel animation is a bit simplistic, though the painted backgrounds are elaborate and often beautiful. There are a few standout moments--notably, one marvelously liquid scene in which the witches conjure up a writhing, flaming (so to speak) demon.

But the odd character design gives everyone rigid, faceted faces, harsh jowls and pronounced bags under their eyes. And the script follows the book so closely that the pacing sometimes becomes awkward. Pratchett's written scenes are often short bursts of humor, metaphor or action without dialogue, and when presented visually, they lack the impact of his language. And of course it's impossible to get the true depth of the book's events or characters from this surface reading of the story's dialogue. Pratchett neophytes may miss a lot of Wyrd Sisters' humor, and most people would be better off reading the book first.

Still, the translation is faithful, the voice actors are well suited to the characters, and fans will enjoy seeking out the many in-jokes (among them, cameos by CMOT Dibbler, the Librarian and the Duck Man.) The DVD bonuses are minimal but fun--short character bios, a brief Pratchett bio and bibliography and some storyboard art. There's also a computer-animated introduction that explains Discworld cosmology in dryly hilarious terms. This may not be High Art, and it's not a substitute for the original, but it's a worthy addition to the Pratchett continuum.

Keep an eye out for Cosgrove-Hall's other Pratchett adaptation, Soul Music, coming from Acorn in early 2001. -- Tasha


Home

News of the Week | On Screen | Off the Shelf | Games | Cool Stuff
Classics | Site of the Week | Interview | Letters | The Cassutt Files


Copyright © 1998-2006, Science Fiction Weekly (TM). All rights reserved. Reproduction in any medium strictly prohibited. Maintained by scifiweekly@scifi.com.