scifi.com navigationscifi.comnewsletterdownloadsfeedbacksearchfaqbboardscifi weeklyscifi wireschedulemoviesshows
 
ALSO IN THIS ISSUE
 Frank Herbert's Dune: Part One
 Frank Herbert's Dune: Part Two
 Frank Herbert's Dune: Part Three

RECENT REVIEWS
 Unbreakable
 The X-Men DVD
 The 6th Day
 Dr. Seuss' How The Grinch Stole Christmas
 Red Planet
 Little Nicky
 Pitch Black Unrated Director's Cut DVD
 Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas Special Edition DVD
 The X-Files: "Within" and "Without"
 Book of Shadows: Blair Witch 2
 Dark Prince: The True Story of Dracula
 Freedom "Alpha Dogs"


Request a review

Gallery

Back issues

Search

Feedback

Submissions

The Staff

Home



Suggestions


Titan A.E. Special Edition DVD

With Earth in ruins, an interstellar race begins to find humanity's last hope

* Titan A.E. Special Edition DVD
* Starring (voices) Matt Damon, Bill Pullman, John Leguizamo, Nathan Lane, Janeane Garofalo and Drew Barrymore
* Written by Ben Edlund, John August and Joss Whedon
* Directed by Don Bluth and Gary Goldman
* 20th Century Fox
* 95 minutes
* MSRP $26.98

By John Sullivan

I n the year 3028, the long history of Earth comes to an end. The alien Drej, frightened by the potential of a new scientific breakthrough by human scientists--the Titan Project--destroy our planet and scatter the remnants of humanity to the stars. During the final evacuation, Cale Tucker (Damon) is separated from his father, a leading scientist on the Titan Project. Cale's father puts him on an evacuation ship, in the care of an alien colleague, and then boards the Titan starship to take it to safety. Cale never sees his father again.

Our Pick: C-

Fifteen years later, humanity is at the bottom of the galactic pecking order. The survivors live mostly in "drifter colonies" tacked together from the hulls of derelict spacecraft. Cale, still bitter about what he sees as his father's abandonment, works on a deep-space salvage station among aliens who look down on "human scum."

His life changes forever when Korso (Pullman) arrives on the station. Korso, another former Titan project member and now captain of the starship Valkyrie, has been looking for Cale. A map, genetically encoded in Cale's DNA, is the only clue to the location of the lost Titan. Korso and his ragtag crew need Cale in order to find the ship, which represents mankind's last chance for a new homeworld of its own.

Unfortunately, the Drej also need Cale's map to find and destroy the Titan forever. And so the galaxy-spanning race is on. As Cale struggles with his destiny, he finds himself drawn to Akima (Barrymore), who grew up in a drifter colony and knows how important a new homeworld is. She has a lot to teach Cale about heroism and hope, but only if he can stay ahead of the relentless Drej long enough to find the Titan, where the answers to his questions await.

Beautiful but baffling

An enormous amount of talent got thrown at Titan A.E., including that of many people whose other work has earned viewers' respect. Unfortunately, combining all that creative input in this case just produced an incoherent mess.

Titan A.E. is often beautiful to look at, but that's the best that can be said for it. It offers practically no characterization, and only the most rudimentary explanation as to why things are happening. As a result, it is difficult to connect with the film's characters as they careen from one chase scene to the next in a story that plays out remarkably like a video game.

That's too bad. The idea of a human diaspora and a hero rising to rebuild mankind's broken spirit could have made for a powerful, emotional story. Actually telling that story would have meant cutting some action sequences, though, and the filmmakers weren't about to do that.

What keeps viewers watching is the mystery waiting at the finish line. What is the Titan Project? Sadly, the payoff provides only a few answers, and those don't help. What was Titan's purpose in the first place? Why are the Drej so upset about it? Why does humanity need it to get a new planet, and why won't that one just get blown up as well? These questions are either ignored completely or given answers so nonsensical that they offer no satisfaction.

The directors' commentary track on the DVD is very revealing. Bluth and Goldman spend much of it grousing about things that didn't turn out as they'd hoped, particularly how studio executives kept tinkering with the movie based on focus-group screenings. The result is a textbook case of how plenty of very talented people can set out with good intentions to tell an ambitious story, and end up with a starship wreck.

I skipped Titan A.E. when it was in theaters because, even in the trailers, the combination of cutting-edge 3-D computer graphics and Don Bluth's classic style of cel animation seemed visually jarring. As it turns out, that is the least of this film's problems. -- John

Back to the top.

Also in this issue: Frank Herbert's Dune: Part One, Frank Herbert's Dune: Part Two and Frank Herbert's Dune: Part Three




Home

News of the Week | On Screen | Off the Shelf | Games | Sound Space
Anime | Site of the Week | Interview | Letters | Excessive Candour


Copyright © 1998-2006, Science Fiction Weekly (TM). All rights reserved. Reproduction in any medium strictly prohibited. Maintained by scifiweekly@scifi.com.