scifi.com navigationscifi.comnewsletterdownloadsfeedbacksearchfaqbboardscifi weeklyscifi wireschedulemoviesshows
 

ALSO IN THIS ISSUE
 New York Nights

RECENT REVIEWS
 Ventus
 The Tranquility Wars
 The Coming
 Wheelers
 Tropic of Creation
 Killing Time
 Zeitgeist
 The Fresco
 The Truth
 Samuel R. Delany's 1984


Request a review

Gallery

Back issues

Search

Feedback

Submissions

The Staff

Home



Suggestions


A Storm of Swords

George R.R. Martin serves up a satisfying third course in his vast fantasy banquet

* A Storm of Swords
* By George R.R. Martin
* Bantam Spectra
* Hardcover, Oct. 2000
* $26.95/$39.95 Canada
* ISBN: 0-553-10663-5

Review by Tasha Robinson
I

n 1996, George R.R. Martin's A Game of Thrones introduced Lord Eddard Stark of Winterfell, head of a noble house and second in command to the ruler of the Seven Kingdoms. Eddard was murdered in Thrones, as was his king, Robert Baratheon. In the sequel, A Clash Of Kings, Eddard's five trueborn children, Robb, Sansa, Arya, Bran and Rickon, and his bastard son, Jon Snow, were scattered as chaos descended and five kings rose to claim power.

Our Pick: A+

A Storm of Swords finds nine-year-old Bran crippled and presumed dead, as he and a few loyal remnants of the Stark household evade capture. Wild little Arya, similarly presumed dead, flees across half the country, looking for shelter, revenge and a family that no longer exists. Sansa remains an abused hostage of Robert Baratheon's widow, Cersei, and her sadistic son, Joffrey, whose claim to Robert's kingdom is solidifying with each new battle. Only 16-year-old Robb Stark, "the King in the North," continues to successfully fight Joffrey's men, though an abrupt and ill-conceived marriage seems likely to cost him his strongest allies.

Desperate to reunite the remnants of her family, Eddard's widow, Catelyn, frees Cersei's twin and lover, Jamie, charging him to return to Cersei and broker Sansa's release. Meanwhile, a world away, Daenerys, the last of the Targaryen line deposed by Robert Baratheon, raises the last dragons in the world and looks for an army capable of returning her to the throne. Jon Snow, sent on an impossible mission to the far north to investigate the upstart king of a demon-haunted realm, attempts to convince an army of shapechangers, giants, rebels and wild folk that he can be trusted with their secrets. Tyrion, Cersei's despised dwarf brother, struggles with a world of intrigue that has suddenly betrayed and discarded him. And Ser Davos Seaworth, a smuggler-turned-knight, attempts to balance his honor with his duty to a king who is falling further and further under the control of a terrifying fanatical sorceress.

Martin looks at the world through each of these characters in turn, roving among their points of view as he continues to build his vastly complex epic story of a kingdom in disarray.

Gods, dragons and cliffhangers

In person, George R.R. Martin is a self-contained, almost dour man whose reserved bearing gives no hint of the vivid world hidden inside his mind. The contrast can be striking, though to be fair, it's sometimes amazing that any one person could contain a story as vast and vivid as the Song of Ice and Fire series. The books bulge with the monumental weight and detail of living history, and burn with passion, obsession, clamor and furor. Storm of Swords is a remarkable accomplishment--a massive, solid block of a book that can barely be lifted one-handed but can barely be put down once begun. At 800 pages, it still serves only to whet appetites for the rest of Martin's suspenseful saga.

At times, Martin's screenwriting roots seem obvious. He makes a point of breaking off chapters at their most dramatic points, alternating between characters to leave readers vibrating with tension on behalf of half a dozen protagonists at once. His structure often seems consciously manipulative, as he deliberately obscures whether certain characters are alive or dead for chapter upon chapter, or places them under the Sword of Damocles and then saws painstakingly at the suspending thread for hundreds of pages at a time. But while his plotting techniques are reminiscent of the familiar cliffhanger-to-cliffhanger style of old movie serials, his character development is both more modern and more daring. Martin specializes in what he calls "gray" characters, protagonists who blend good and bad motives, actions and reactions so thoroughly that it's impossible to pigeonhole them quickly as "heroes" and "villains." Instead, they're forced to be "humans," which is far more compelling.

Like its predecessors, Storm of Swords is packed with personal details--the sights and sounds and smells of real life in a retooled Middle Ages setting. It's densely convoluted and sprawling in its attempts to portray an entire world of events at once, but it never loses sight of the mundane microcosms of individual lives. The resulting blend is a soaring fantasy packed with wars, gods and dragons that still feels as tangible, as comfortable, and as enveloping as a favorite pair of gloves. Martin's magnum opus is a powerful and stunning achievement. Don't miss it.

If you can find it, Martin's out-of-print first novel, Dying of the Light, is a wonderful read for fans of this series. It's science fiction rather than medieval fantasy, but more than any of Martin's other books, it uses the same blend of resonant, believable characters, intricate plotting, detailed descriptions and intense emotions that make Martin's best work so memorable. -- Tasha

Back to the top.

Also in this issue: New York Nights




Home

News of the Week | On Screen | Off the Shelf | Classics
Cool Stuff | Games | Site of the Week | Letters | Interview


Copyright © 1998-2006, Science Fiction Weekly (TM). All rights reserved. Reproduction in any medium strictly prohibited. Maintained by scifiweekly@scifi.com.