scifi.com navigationscifi.comnewsletterdownloadsfeedbacksearchfaqbboardscifi weeklyscifi wireschedulemoviesshows
 
ALSO IN THIS ISSUE
 Pulgasari

RECENT REVIEWS
 Frank Herbert's Dune: Part One
 Frank Herbert's Dune: Part Two
 Frank Herbert's Dune: Part Three
 Titan A.E. Special Edition DVD
 Unbreakable
 The X-Men DVD
 The 6th Day
 Dr. Seuss' How The Grinch Stole Christmas
 Red Planet
 Little Nicky
 Pitch Black Unrated Director's Cut DVD
 Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas Special Edition DVD


Request a review

Gallery

Back issues

Search

Feedback

Submissions

The Staff

Home



Suggestions


Dungeons & Dragons

Instead of soaring, this dragon only lays an egg

* Dungeons & Dragons
* Starring Jeremy Irons, Justin Whalin, Marlon Wayans, Zoe McLellan, Thora Birch
* Directed by Courtney Solomon
* Written by Topper Lilien and Carroll Cartwright
* New Line
* Rated PG-13
* Premieres Dec. 8

By Patrick Lee

I n the mystical Empire of Izmer, the evil mage Profion (Irons) and his chief henchman, Damodar (Bruce Payne), believe that the child Empress Savina (Birch) wants to undermine their power. How? Savina believes that commoners and mages alike should be treated equally--the very idea!

Our Pick: D

So Profion conspires to acquire magic scepters that will allow him to control dragons, and thereby consolidate his grip on the Council of Mages. Savina has a scepter which allows her to control gold dragons. Profion has one, but it doesn't work very well. But the true power resides in the mysterious Rod of Savrille, which would allow the bearer to master red dragons.

Savina's mage mentor, Vildan Vildir (Edward Jewesbury), has a map that shows the way to the Rod of Savrille, which has been lost. Profion dispatches Damodar and his crimson soldiers to Izmer's Magic School to steal the map from Vildir.

But Profion hasn't counted on the presence of the dashing thief Ridley (Whalin) and his comic sidekick, Snails (Wayans), who have broken into the school to steal treasures. When Damodar attacks Vildir, the mage gives the map to his apprentice, Marina (McLellan). The thieves help Marina escape the school with the precious map.

Marina persuades the reluctant thieves to join her, despite their misgivings about helping a mage-in-training. They are joined by the irascible dwarf Elwood Gutworthy (Lee Arenberg), who sees that there may be a reward involved.

Ridley discovers one of the map's secrets, and leads the band to the Guild of Thieves, where they may recover a magic stone, the Eye of the Dragon. But Damodar isn't far behind. Can Marina and Ridley overcome their differences to find the Rod before Profion? The future of the Empress--and Izmer--hangs in the balance.

Two-dimensional as a trading card

Dungeons & Dragons is a labor of love for Courtney Solomon, a 30-year-old Canadian who makes his feature directorial debut with this ambitious $36 million movie, backed by The Matrix producer Joel Silver. So it seems almost curmudgeonly to say that D&D is awful on almost every level. But it is, and it's unlikely anyone but the most fanatic D&D gamers will see much to recommend in it.

The trouble starts with the amateurish script, which cribs from much better movies, like Star Wars and Raiders of the Lost Ark. The script relies much too heavily on conventions of the game, though the story, we are told, is Solomon's own. The action stops dead every now and then for a major character to provide exposition on why they must get this magic scroll or negotiate that perilous maze. The quests seem arbitrary and pointless.

The characters are as two-dimensional as game cards. In particular, Wayans' character rivals Jar Jar Binks as an offensive squealing Stepin Fetchit caricature. The dialogue is cringe-worthy. "Be prepared for a lesson in pain!" Damodar growls at one point. Moreover, the jokes are so stale, not a single person in a preview audience uttered so much as a chuckle.

Much attention went into the production design of the film, which was shot in Prague. But the result is a curiously generic medieval European look that has been done much better in scores of other films.

The actors don't help much. Birch is appealing but miscast; at one point, she looks like she's going to topple off her shoes. The others mug more than perform. Irons, normally a subtle and fascinating actor, is allowed to run completely out of control, leering and gnashing his teeth, throwing his arms out and howling like a madman. Only Lee Arenberg is mildly amusing as the feculent dwarf.

About the only thing to like is the finale, in which airborne dragons strafe Izmer. But even the artful visual effects feel wasted.

D&D is another in a long, sad line of game-inspired movies, from Mortal Kombat to Street Fighter to Pokemon. Can't we just say game over? -- Patrick

Back to the top.

Also in this issue: Pulgasari




Home

News of the Week | On Screen | Off the Shelf | Classics
Cool Stuff | Games | Site of the Week | Letters | Interview


Copyright © 1998-2006, Science Fiction Weekly (TM). All rights reserved. Reproduction in any medium strictly prohibited. Maintained by scifiweekly@scifi.com.