scifi.com navigationscifi.comnewsletterdownloadsfeedbacksearchfaqbboardscifi weeklyscifi wireschedulemoviesshows
 
ALSO IN THIS ISSUE
 A.I.: Artificial Intelligence
 Dr. Dolittle 2
 Stargate SG-1

RECENT REVIEWS
 Tomb Raider
 Ice From the Sun
 Jin-Roh: The Wolf Brigade
 Evolution
 Superman The Movie--Special Edition DVD
 Atlantis: The Lost Empire
 Witchblade
 The Animal
 Time Squad
 The X-Files 3rd Season DVD


Request a review

Gallery

Back issues

Search

Feedback

Submissions

The Staff

Home



Suggestions


On The Edge

Acclaimed actresses make their directorial debuts in Showtime's trilogy of the fantastic

*On The Edge
*Starring John Goodman, Anthony LaPaglia and Andie MacDowell
*Directorial debuts by Helen Mirren ("Happy Birthday"), Mary Stuart Masterson ("The Other Side") and Anne Heche ("Reaching Normal")
*Teleplays by Crispin Whittell ("Happy Birthday"), Mary Stuart Masterson ("The Other Side") and Anne Heche ("Reaching Normal")
*Produced by Jana Sue Memel
*Showtime
*Series premiere airs Friday, June 29, 8:00 p.m. ET/PT

By Kathie Huddleston

A s part of Showtime's Oscar-winning film series "Directed By," On The Edge puts Mirren, Masterson and Heche at the helm for a science-fiction trilogy of tales. As the film opens, an arrogant movie mogul (Scott Lowell) thinks he knows what the public wants. That is, until a strange temp (Kathleen Wilhoite) forces him to watch three TV "lessons" to show him the error of his ways.

Our Pick: C+

In "Happy Birthday," Hannah (Sydney Tamiia Poitier) is at the top of her class until she's tossed out of school by the dean (Goodman) just before graduation. In a future with too many people, too many bugs and a central computer that controls everything, she's told she's too smart and should get a cranial "adjustment" so she'll be happy. Hannah decides there's only one thing to do: find the secret central computer and make her own "adjustment."

In "The Other Side," Maas (LaPaglia) is a brilliant pioneer in the field of artificial intelligence, but unfortunately he's dying. He secretly creates a biobot clone in an attempt at immortality. When a woman from his past, Anna (Karen Sillas), is brought onto his project to help solve a logic problem, Maas' clone decides the real Maas is in the way, especially concerning the lovely Anna.

In "Reaching Normal," housewife Lisa Waverly's (MacDowell) life may be dull and static, but it's the voices she hears and the things she sees that are driving her mad. When she meets a strange man (Paul Rudd), she's suddenly telepathically connected to him. And now that she's met someone who can read her mind, how can she ever go back to her normal life?

Uneven mix not quite edgy enough

Like many anthology films, On The Edge is an uneven mix of tales that have little in common with each other and, except for the first story, cover science-fiction territory that is far too familiar. While it's nice to see actresses Mirren, Masterson and Heche given a chance to strut their stuff, there's not a lot to set this anthology apart from any other besides an impressive assortment of guest stars.

By far the best of the bunch in story and presentation is "Happy Birthday," which is based on the Keith Laumer short story "Placement Test." This funny and bizarre tale has an almost comic-book-like flavor, and it's easy to see the promise Mirren has as a director as she juggles an array of guest stars with the often surprising story.

The other two shorts are mediocre stories that have been told before, and better. "The Other Side," based on Bruce Holland Rogers' short story "Lifeboat on a Burning Sea," is the type of scientific morality tale that has been done much more effectively on The Outer Limits. "Reaching Normal," from the Walter M. Miller Jr. short story, "Command Performance," has more potential to develop an interesting story, and MacDowell, Rudd and Alan Rosenberg give nice performances. However, the script never comes together well enough to be effective. These last two shorts feel underdeveloped and thin. The wraparound story about the movie mogul, directed by Memel, is a waste of time and has nothing to do with the shorts that are presented.

The biggest problem with On The Edge is that, with the exception of "Happy Birthday," it's just not very edgy. What it ultimately comes down to is that it's not about the acting or the directing or the production values. It's about the story that's being told. And with the one exception, we've seen it all before.

Mirren's debut was especially impressive. It's good and surprising to see these women taking a chance by making their directorial debuts with science-fiction material. Let's hope these wonderful actresses take the chance again in the future, just with a little more edge next time. -- Kathie

Back to the top.

Also in this issue: A.I.: Artificial Intelligence, Dr. Dolittle 2 and Stargate SG-1




Home

News of the Week | On Screen | Off the Shelf | Classics
Cool Stuff | Games | Site of the Week | Letters | Interview


Copyright © 1998-2006, Science Fiction Weekly (TM). All rights reserved. Reproduction in any medium strictly prohibited. Maintained by scifiweekly@scifi.com.