scifi.com navigationscifi.comnewsletterdownloadsfeedbacksearchfaqbboardscifi weeklyscifi wireschedulemoviesshows
 
ALSO IN THIS ISSUE
 Spider-Man
 Lost Voyage
 The Chronology Protection Case

RECENT REVIEWS
 Jason X
 Citizen Toxie: The Toxic Avenger 4
 The Scorpion King
 Living with the Dead
 Frailty
 Human Nature
 Disappearance
 Project Viper
 Star Trek: The Next Generation—Season One DVD
 Night of the Living Dead: Millennium Edition


Request a review

Gallery

Back issues

Search

Feedback

Submissions

The Staff

Home



Suggestions


Dinotopia

There's trouble in almost-paradise for two brothers who discover a land that time forgot

*Dinotopia
*Starring Tyron Leitso, Wentworth Miller, Katie Carr and Alice Krige
*Directed by Marco Brambilla
*Written by Simon Moore
*ABC
*Premieres Sunday, May 12 (7 p.m.), Monday, May 13 (8 p.m.) and Tuesday, May 14 (8 p.m.) ET/PT

By Kathie Huddleston

A BC finally premieres its long-awaited six-hour miniseries Dinotopia just in time for May sweeps. Based on the books by James Gurney, Dinotopia opens as wealthy American Frank Scott (Stuart Wilson) takes his sons, David and Karl, on a trip island-hopping. They hit a sudden storm and the plane goes down, taking Frank with it. David (Miller) and Karl (Leitso) manage to swim to a nearby island, where they soon discover they are in a land unlike any they've ever seen before—a place where humans and dinosaurs seem to co-exist.

Our Pick: B

They end up on a perilous trip to Waterfall City, where they hope to find the resources that might get them home. Joining them on their trip is Marion (Carr), a young woman who is studying to be the leader of her people. The brothers quickly learn that while most dinosaurs are friendly, the carnivorous ones aren't, and they barely escape a T-rex attack.

When they arrive in Waterfall City, the off-worlders are welcomed by Mayor Waldo (Jim Carter) and the city's citizens. Unfortunately, they are told there is no way off Dinotopia. The brothers are befriended by a librarian Stenonychosaurus named Zippo, who speaks 17 human and Saurian languages, and they begin to learn about their new home. As David starts to embrace the Dinotopian way, Karl finds himself at odds with his new surroundings.

The brothers are sent to the island's academy to learn to become Dinotopians. When they're given their assignments, the studious David is sent to Skybax Corps training to learn how to fly a pterosaur and the cynical Karl is assigned to oversee the birth of an infant Chasmosaurus named 26.

As Karl and David struggle with their new roles and each other, they discover that there is trouble in paradise. The sunstones, Dinotopia's energy source, are beginning to fail, threatening to plunge the entire island into peril. Without the sunstones there is nothing to keep the carnivores at bay. Unfortunately for the brothers, the only way to save Dinotopia may be to break the island's most sacred rules by taking a dangerous journey to a mythical place known as The World Beneath.

A stunning special-effects spectacular

Move over, Jurassic Park—dinosaurs are walking the earth again, but this time on the small screen. Dinotopia is an impressive special-effects extravaganza that creates an environment where humans and dinosaurs interact in a realistic way. The miniseries is visually stunning, but the story doesn't quite hold up to the special effects.

The tale about two brothers who end up in Dinotopia is a dual coming-of-age story told in epic proportions. While the story could have degenerated into the standard television storytelling of convenient good and evil, it never quite goes there. The first two parts of the miniseries focus on the brothers' struggles in becoming Dinotopians, before heading into more standard adventure in the final hour as they try to save the world, at least the world of Dinotopia.

Unfortunately, when the real action begins to happen, the dinosaur characters are left behind and the tale loses its unique flavor. Although the baby dinosaur 26 is very cute, the only interactive dinosaur is Zippo. He's a fun character to have around, whether he's stumbling around in the library or playing pingpong with Karl. However, not enough is done with him and there are no other dinosaurs around who get a chance to do much.

While there are some other problems with the way the tale winds up, it comes down to the fact that there just aren't many surprises at the end of the story. We know pretty much how things are going to end, and they do. It's vaguely unsatisfying, but maybe that's because it should have been great.

Dinotopia already has a vote of confidence from ABC. A new series with a different cast has already gone into production. James Gurney has developed a rich universe to draw from and the series has excellent potential. As for this Dinotopia miniseries, it may not be perfect, but it's still a visual feast and good entertainment. — Kathie

Back to the top.

Also in this issue: Spider-Man, Lost Voyage and The Chronology Protection Case




Home

News of the Week | On Screen | Off the Shelf | Games | Sound Space
Anime | Site of the Week | Interview | Letters | Lab Notes


Copyright © 1998-2006, Science Fiction Weekly (TM). All rights reserved. Reproduction in any medium strictly prohibited. Maintained by scifiweekly@scifi.com.