scifi.com navigationscifi.comnewsletterdownloadsfeedbacksearchfaqbboardscifi weeklyscifi wireschedulemoviesshows
RECENT REVIEWS
 The War Game
 Lest Darkness Fall
 Swords and Deviltry
 Battlefield Earth: A Saga of the Year 3000
 The Blob
 Triton
 Altered States
 Queen of Outer Space
 Beetlejuice
 Galaxies


Request a review

Gallery

Back issues

Search

Feedback

Submissions

The Staff

Home



Suggestions


Quest for Fire

They can't survive without fire—but, unfortunately, they live in a world without matches

*Quest for Fire
*Starring Everett McGill, Rae Dawn Chong, Ron Perlman and Nameer El-Hadi
* Special languages created by Anthony Burgess
*Screenplay by Gerard Brach, from the novel by J.H. Rosny
*Directed by Jean-Jacques Annaud
*100 min.
*1982

Review by Adam-Troy Castro

The Ulam tribe ekes out a precarious existence 80,000 years ago, their lives utterly dependent on the fire they carry from place to place in a special bowl. They honor the fire and respect its power, especially since their talent at preserving it is not accompanied by the skill to start new fires at will. This shortcoming proves a major disaster when the tribe is forced to flee an all-out assault by another tribe. Ousted from their sheltering cave, the Ulam face death by freezing when their only existing flame is dunked in a nearby swamp.

Our Pick: A

The only solution is for somebody to go out and find more fire, and the task falls to Naoh (McGill) and his two companions (Perlman, El-Hadi). Leaving the Ulam behind, they search the countryside for another life-preserving flame. Along the way, they face numerous dangers, including a hungry sabertooth and a band of marauding cannibals.

It is while battling the cannibals, and stealing their fire, that the trio discovers something that may be even more helpful in the long run. The newly freed prisoners of the cannibals include Ika (Chong), a member of the Ivaka tribe, who adorn themselves with clay markings, and who have pioneered many innovations far beyond the relatively primitive Ulam: among them laughter, the missionary position and (most importantly) the means of starting fire. Of course, it isn't long before Naoh realizes he wants more than fire from the Ivaka. He wants Ika along permanently ...

A film that starts more fires than one

There have been so many caveman movies over the years that they qualify as a separate genre. Most, like Quest for Fire, used made-up primitive languages rather than contemporary speech, but that was the only real concession to period flavor. Most threw accuracy to the winds and placed their prehistoric humans in close proximity with dinosaurs, of either the stop-motion or the poorly-disguised-giant-Gila-monster variety.

Quest for Fire was different. No less fanciful—in that we're expected to believe that its trio of questing heroes can travel all the way from a frozen swamp in Europe to a warm plain in Africa and return before the miserable tribe they left behind lose any members or even change their seating positions—it nevertheless deserves a place of honor among its fellow specimens for its sense of verisimilitude. These cavemen aren't photogenic, well-scrubbed stars in fake-fur bikinis. They're dirty, they're vulnerable to the elements, they have bad teeth, they seem to be discovering everything around them for the first time ... and they seem far more human than most of the protagonists of more conventional films. Their adventures seem to matter.

The film seems to have everything. There's humor, perhaps best embodied by the sequence where our heroes, treed by a hungry lion, eat every leaf on every branch while they wait for the persistent feline to leave. There's martial artistry, as in the bloody life-and-death battle with a tribe of cannibals. There's ribaldry: a bit of business where a captive finds himself obliged to service all the women of the clay people. There's slapstick: a scene near the end where one character exercises his recent discovery that a rock, landing on an unsuspecting victim's head, is funny. There's adventure, there's horror, there's a series of hair's-breadth escapes, and there's even wonder. The film genuinely makes you feel the awe its primitive heroes feel for innovations, like fire, that the modern world takes for granted.

Finally, there's the love story, which the film would have us consider the first love story. Naoh, driven to distraction by the constant jabbering of the clay woman so winsomely played by Rae Dawn Chong, ultimately decides he can't live without her. It's a decision that's even more affecting when it comes from a hero whose culture has not yet developed the concept of romantic love. He clearly feels what he feels. He clearly doesn't understand why. And though she's clearly more advanced than he is, she feels it too. It's a love story without understandable dialogue that nevertheless resonates and lingers.

Philip Sarde's love theme is a minor triumph. Jean-Jacques Annaud's peculiar genius for dirt as stage dressing was also used to great effect in his adaptation of Umberto Eco's The Name of the Rose. — Adam-Troy

Back to the top.




Home

News of the Week | On Screen | Off the Shelf | Games | Cool Stuff
Classics | Site of the Week | Interview | Letters | The Cassutt Files


Copyright © 1998-2006, Science Fiction Weekly (TM). All rights reserved. Reproduction in any medium strictly prohibited. Maintained by scifiweekly@scifi.com.