scifi.com navigationscifi.comnewsletterdownloadsfeedbacksearchfaqbboardscifi weeklyscifi wireschedulemoviesshows
 
ALSO IN THIS ISSUE
 Elektra
 Racing Stripes
 Point Pleasant Series Premiere
 Young Blades Series Premiere

RECENT REVIEWS
 White Noise
 The Ultimate Matrix Collection DVD
 Carnivàle Season-One DVD
 Xena: Warrior Princess Season-Five DVD
 Sky Blue
 Carnivàle Season-Two Premiere
 Medium Series Premiere
 Buck Rogers in the 25th Century: The Complete Series DVD
 Andrew Lloyd Webber's The Phantom of the Opera
 Darkness


Request a review

Gallery

Back issues

Search

Feedback

Submissions

The Staff

Home



Suggestions


Appleseed

After the Earth's elders propose that a devastating war end with the destruction of humanity, one woman fights back

*Appleseed
*Starring Jennifer Proud, James Lyon and Mia Bradly
*Directed by Shinji Aramaki
*Written by Haruka Handa and Tsutomu Kamishiro
*Geneon Entertainment
*Rated R
*Opened Jan. 14, 2005

By Todd Gilchrist

T he year is 2131, and the world is rebuilding after a devastating war. While massive industrial centers spring up and revive humanity from apocalyptic decimation, Deunan Knute (Proud) knows nothing of the peace and continues to fight a battle that has long since ended: Mechanical predators remain active in the wastelands, determined to destroy all human life. During an attack by a band of mechanical predators, she is rescued by a military patrol from the city of Olympus and finds herself thrust into the center of a bustling new culture in which humans and robots co-exist peacefully.

Our Pick: C-

After a short-lived reunion with her presumed-dead lover Briareos (Lyon), Deunan becomes the central figure in a growing rift between humans and their genetically engineered progeny; specifically, a human clone named Hitomi (Bradly) explains that the regular armies resent their bioroid counterparts and want to reclaim control of Olympus for themselves. Deunan soon discovers that her mother was the inventor of bioroid technology, and was killed by Olympus' seven elders when she refused to cede control of it.

Now, on the eve of man's greatest triumph, the elders propose that humanity be destroyed and replaced by bioroids, which were originally designed to provide a harmonious balance against mankind's destructive impulses. At the same time, the human armies will stop at nothing to wrench control of Olympus from the bioroid leader Athena and the increasingly illogical decisions of the elders. Only Deunan can decipher what greater truth hides behind these lies, and what humanity's future will be. Aided only by Briareos, Hitomi and a weapons designer names Yoshi, Deunan must fight untold hordes of opponents to provide Athena with the salvation of humanity and preserve the planet for all mankind.

Beauty is only cel deep

Appleseed is the third anime (or Asian animation) effort to make it to American shores in the past 12 months, following Ghost in the Shell 2 and Sky Blue, and by far the least of those entries. Not because of the way it looks, mind you; seldom have images been so vividly and distinctively rendered as they are here. But director Shinji Aramaki, or perhaps his screenwriters, Haruka Handa and Tsutomu Kamishiro, seem to possess little ability when it comes to telling a story that's half as compelling as the animation it accompanies.

The film's formula works like an assembly line of conflict, moving from the physical to the intellectual to the emotional in repetitive succession without building much in the way of suspense or depth; it says much that the press notes highlight the musical acts employed for the soundtrack but make no mention of the actors used to voice the characters. There's some big fight scene, set to the thump of a techno tune by the likes of Paul Oakenfold, Boom Boom Satellites or Basement Jaxx; then a bunch of talking about what's going on—most of which is technobabble no one understands or cares about; and then some moral or emotional quandary ("I lost you once and don't want to again!") drawn far too simply to register with audiences who embrace the conceptual complexity of the animation.

Meanwhile, the world contained in the film is depressingly familiar to animation fans—yet another gleaming, post-apocalyptic dystopia from the only country to have survived an H-bomb—and the characters are surprisingly thin for having come from a longstanding and well-reputed series of comic books. The animation, which is described as "3-D live anime," uplifts the proceedings as long as there's an easy adversary to overcome; if there's a tank to blow up or robot to wreck, you'll be completely entertained. But Appleseed's purpose is to ask, yet again, the age-old question "Are humans doomed to destroy themselves?"; whether or not that answer is yes, movies like this show that some of their art forms, at the very least, are rapidly imploding.

Of the anime films I've seen over the past year, this was the one I anticipated the most—I'd collected the comics as a kid—but ultimately this was the most disappointing. I'm always willing to accept a degree of implausibility that comes with creating a futuristic science-fiction fantasy film; I'll buy the prospect of a flying car without needing to understand the science behind it. This, ultimately, underscores what's wrong with Appleseed: The filmmakers spend too much time trying to justify their futuristic world, and not enough actually exploring it. I'd like to think that these problems didn't exist in the Japanese-language version, because what was gained in translation ultimately comes as a loss to the audience; let's hope those proposed sequels forgo the heavy-handed explanations and (literally) cut to the chase. —Todd

Back to the top.

Also in this issue: Elektra, Racing Stripes, Point Pleasant Series Premiere and Young Blades Series Premiere




Home

News of the Week | On Screen | Off the Shelf | Games | Cool Stuff
Classics | Site of the Week | Interview | Letters | The Cassutt Files


Copyright © 1998-2006, Science Fiction Weekly (TM). All rights reserved. Reproduction in any medium strictly prohibited. Maintained by scifiweekly@scifi.com.