ON SCREEN


RECENT REVIEWS
 * Space Marines
 * Crime Traveller
 * The Empire Strikes Back: Special Edition
 * Asteroid
 * MST3K: The Amazing Colossal Man
 * Star Wars Special Edition
 * Mystery Science Theater, Season 8
 * The Relic
 * Mars Attacks!
 * L5: First City in Space
 * Star Trek: First Contact
 * The Cold Equations
 * The X-Files (videotape)
 * Alien Nation: The Enemy Within



 Join SF writer, editor, critic and scholar John Clute for the first installment of his new column, Excessive Candour.


Request a review

Letters

Gallery

Back issues

Search

Feedback

Submissions

The Staff

Home



Suggestions

The Return of the Jedi: Special Edition

Luke takes on Darth Vader and the Emperor singlehandedly

* The Return of the Jedi: Special Edition
* Rated PG
* Starring Mark Hamill, Carrie Fisher, Harrison Ford
* 145 Minutes

Review by Brooks Peck

This third chapter of the Star Wars trilogy opens on a dark note. Han Solo is sealed in carbonite and serves as a wall hanging for the evil crime lord Jabba the Hutt. Soon Princess Leia, Chewbacca and the droids also fall into Jabba's clutches. Meanwhile, the Empire has nearly completed a bigger, badder Death Star with which to crush the Rebel Alliance forever.

Our Pick: A

The big change is in Luke Skywalker. No longer a whiny, insecure boy, Luke has traded his farmer's smock for the black vestments of a Jedi Knight. Rippling with the Force, he comes to Jabba's palace, makes light-sabre mincemeat of that nest of depravity, and rescues his friends.

Returning to Dagobah, Luke's tutor Yoda tells him that his training will only be complete after he challenges his father, Darth Vader. Luke disagrees, feeling that it's not too late to save Vader from the dark side of the Force.

Meanwhile, his cohorts launch a daring plan: to destroy the under-construction Death Star orbiting Endor with the Emperor on board. Along the way they enlist the aid of Endor's plump and primitive natives, the Ewoks. Luke surrenders in order to confront Vader, and becomes embroiled in a battle with the Emperor to save himself and his father from the dark side. And both the Death Star and Endor turn out to be better protected than supposed, giving the rebels quite a hot reception. . . .

Still cool, but still cute

Although bursting with spectacular effects, The Return of the Jedi is arguably the weakest film in the trilogy. Unlike the first two, this movie radiates an awareness that it's part of a pop culture sensation, and the actors likewise exude a smarmy complacency. There's also an obvious effort to cute it up, as evidenced by the teddy-bear Ewoks, a far cry from the raw, alien feel of the Mos Eisley bar scene in Star Wars.

New footage in this Special Edition Jedi includes a brand new musical number by a set of singers (some live, some digital) at Jabba's palace. This scene is quite well integrated with the original film, but also on the cute side. The other big addition is at the end when viewers are shown, on a variety of worlds, the newly-freed inhabitants of the galaxy dancing and singing in the streets in joyful celebration. These scenes give a good sense of the far-reaching repercussions of the victory, and they look great.

Much of the original Jedi is still terrific. It's wonderful to see Luke get his act together and start kicking butt. The vile Emperor oozes treachery and malice. And the space battle around Endor is a breathtaking ride; seeing it on the big screen alone is worth the price of admission. These features and others are more than enough to counterbalance the mistakes, and they make this an excellent movie.

I thought I was grown up and mature, but the trilogy still has the power to grab my emotions and shake them like an old bucket of paint. -- Brooks



Home

News of the Week | Off the Shelf | On Screen | Classic Sci-Fi
Sci-Fi Site of the Week | Anime | Cool Sci-Fi Stuff | Games


Copyright © 1997, Science Fiction Weekly (TM). All rights reserved. Reproduction in any medium strictly prohibited. Maintained by scifiweekly@scifi.com.