scifi.com navigationscifi.comnewsletterdownloadsfeedbacksearchfaqbboardscifi weeklyscifi wireschedulemoviesshows
 
ALSO IN THIS ISSUE
 A Sound of Thunder
 Hood of the Living Dead DVD

RECENT REVIEWS
 The Cave
 The Brothers Grimm
 Space Ghost Coast to Coast: Volume-Three DVD
 Valiant
 3rd Rock From the Sun Season-One DVD
 They Came Back DVD
 The Skeleton Key
 The Stone Raft DVD
 Marronnier DVD
 2046


Request a review

Gallery

Back issues

Search

Feedback

Submissions

The Staff

Home



Suggestions


Lost
Season-One DVD

For the last survivors of a Pacific jet crash, a desert island will turn out to be closer to Hell than Paradise

*Lost Season-One DVD
*Starring Matthew Fox, Evangeline Lilly, Josh Holloway, Terry O'Quinn and Naveen Andrews
*Created by Jeffrey Lieber, J.J. Abrams and Damon Lindelof
*Seven-disc set
*Buena Vista Home Entertainment
*MSRP: $59.99

By Adam-Troy Castro

A n Oceanic Airlines flight from Australia to Los Angeles loses radio contact, goes off-course and breaks up in midair. It's impossible for anybody to make it. But more than four dozen people survive the crash on an uncharted desert island, which almost right away turns out to be inhabited by a mysterious, unseen monster, among other phenomena that defy easy explanation.

Our Pick: A

The castaways include troubled surgeon Jack (Fox), wanted fugitive Kate (Lilly), Iraqi officer Sayid (Andrews), affable millionaire Hurley (Jorge Garcia) and the downright odd, self-styled survivalist John Locke (O'Quinn). Their backstories, revealed in flashback once the season progresses, reveal tragic histories that, in several cases, enter the realm of the paranormal. One seems to be under a curse. Another is fleeing a prophecy. The disability of another is restored at the moment of the crash. Further dark developments reveal that the island is already inhabited, by previous castaways who include the half-mad French woman Rosseau (Mira Furlan), the downright murderous Ethan (William Mapother), and even more threatening, largely unseen "Others."

As dangers proliferate, several castaways fail to survive their first 40 days on the island. Michael Dawson (Harold Perrineau), his son Walt (Malcolm David Kelley), scruffy con man Sawyer (Holloway) and unwilling Korean gangster Jin Kwon (Daniel Dae Kim) put all their hopes on the construction of a raft. But will the forces controlling the island even permit them to leave? And what's hidden underneath that unseen hatch in the jungle?

Slowly unravelling secrets

Lost is that rarity: A smash hit that deserves to be. Rich with character interaction, unrelenting suspense and moments of startling revelation, it demands attention from its stunning first 15 minutes and, if anything, gets more and more compelling as it bumps along. Better yet, it rewards obsessive viewing by planting a wealth of small details that don't pay off until many episodes later: Among them, just what's going on with Locke, the one castaway who actually seems cheery in the aftermath of the disaster.

The first season comes off as an organic whole, with all the deepening and proliferating mysteries of the island hinting at a some kind of involved, uncanny but very specific explanation. Everything feels planned. The one genuine danger evaded so far, unfortunately a real one given the input of Alias creator J.J. Abrams, is that the plan might ultimately amount to making things up on the fly. If the creators don't know where they're going with this thing, expect building viewer frustration by season three.

DVD extras include a visit to the set by talk show maven Jimmy Kimmel (who ultimately encounters the show's unseen monster close up) and "Tales from the Island" that include a featurette on the creation of the backstory's fictional rock band Driveshaft. "The Art of Matthew Fox" features black-and-white production photographs by the actor. "The Genesis of Lost" details how a nebulous concept about castaways morphed into the science-fiction show it is today. Several episodes have extensive commentaries. The commentary for episode four, "Walkabout," with its stunning revelation about castaway John Locke, establishes that the forces behind the scenes wanted to give the episode the hilariously apt title "Lord of the Files."

Most fascinating are the audition tapes of the various regulars, dating back to an early script in which the doctor, Jack, died in the first episode. In that draft, Kate speaks lines in which she starts to assume leadership of the castaways. Aside from this tantalizing glimpse of a storyline abandoned, we are also treated to actors reading for parts other than those they were eventually awarded. Yunjin Kim, who plays Sun, acquits herself well reading for Kate. Meanwhile, Matthew Fox, who became Jack, is shown reading for both that role and for the role of sleazebag con man Sawyer. (He's downright psychotic as Sawyer.) Rotund Jorge Garcia, who became everybody's favorite as the star-crossed Hurley, also reads for Sawyer, not quite managing that role's dangerous intensity. One suspects that if he'd gotten the part, it wouldn't have featured quite as many shirtless scenes. The best audition? Young Malcolm David Kelley, who shows real wonder during Locke's monologue on Backgammon.

You've got Arzt on you, dude. —Adam-Troy

Back to the top.

Also in this issue: A Sound of Thunder and Hood of the Living Dead DVD




Home

News of the Week | On Screen | Off the Shelf | Games | Sound Space
Anime | Site of the Week | Interview | Letters | Excessive Candour


Copyright © 1998-2006, Science Fiction Weekly (TM). All rights reserved. Reproduction in any medium strictly prohibited. Maintained by scifiweekly@scifi.com.