scifi.com logohome
NEW! FIDGIT GAME BLOGGAME CENTERBLOGSDOWNLOADSMEMBERSHIPFAQSEARCHHELPFULL EPISODESVIDEOSHOWSSCHEDULESCI FI WIRESCI FI WEEKLYDVICEMOBILESTOREFORUMS
A Scanner Darkly
Earth Is Room Enough
Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom
Zothique
The World, the Flesh, and the Devil
The Birds
Batman
A Fall of Moondust
Showboat World
Edward Scissorhands
May 29, 2001

Brazil

Terry Gilliam's dystopic masterpiece is a movie that Hollywood tried to destroy rather than release
Brazil
Directed by Terry Gilliam
Starring Jonathan Pryce, Kim Greist, Robert De Niro, Ian Holm and Bob Hoskins
Running time 131 minutes (director's cut 142 minutes)
Rated R
By Adam-Troy Castro
In the nightmarish near-future, galloping bureaucracy and increasing social decay have produced a society where man can be condemned to death simply for working as a plumber without a license. Nothing works well, not elevators, not computers and certainly not the bureaucracy; entire lives can be destroyed by mere glitches in paperwork. The countryside is a blasted plain hidden by billboards, and fancy restaurants serve disgusting green glop decorated with cards depicting the meals the wealthy patrons are supposed to imagine they’re eating.

One day, a swatted fly falls into a teletype, altering an arrest order for an outlaw plumbing-and-heating man named Tuttle (Robert De Niro). A heavily armed troop of secret policemen breaks into the home of an innocent named Buttle, dragging him away from his terrified wife and family. His upstairs neighbor, a truck driver named Jill (Kim Greist) knows the arrest is wrong and vows to find him.

Elsewhere, a minor bureaucrat named Lowry (Jonathan Pryce) ekes out a living at the Ministry of Information, where he is invaluable to his nervous boss, Mr. Kurtzmann (Ian Holm). Although pressed by his youth-obsessed mother (Kathryn Helmond) and his state-torturer friend Jack (Michael Palin) to accept a big promotion, Lowry prefers to stay where he is, perhaps believing himself safer that way. If he has any joy in life at all, it’s in his dreams, where he nightly casts himself as a dashing armored hero on a quest to rescue a beautiful fantasy woman (also Greist).

One night, Lowry’s heating goes blooey. Before he can get the state-sanctioned plumbers to come out for emergency repairs, the pistol-packing Tuttle swoops to the rescue instead. The official state plumber (Bob Hoskins), a pretty nasty piece of work, shows up and subsequently does everything he can to make Lowry’s life miserable. That, and Lowry’s discovery of the real Jill, whose investigations of Buttle’s arrest places her in serious danger of arrest by the secret police, makes Lowry’s carefully ordered life fall to pieces. He becomes obsessed with the thought of saving Jill from the law. But he can barely handle his own life. Won't he just make matters worse?

Something completely different
Brazil, the brainchild of Monty Python’s Terry Gilliam, is a frustrating film at times. Its pace is wonky, sometimes racing from development to development without stopping to explain them, other times hammering basic points into the wall. The dream sequences, integral as they are, go on too long (especially the final one, which continues well past its narrative point is made). Its place in the pantheon of dystopic greats is a tribute to its many compensatory virtues, which range from a wealth of throwaway verbal gags to its persuasive nightmare vision of a society buried beneath the weight of runaway bureaucratic incompetence.

The film is also a visual feast. Take an early establishing shot of Lowry’s workplace: a vast, frenetic hive of identical drones and even more identical office boys, racing around in circles collecting and distributing paper to convince the suspicious boss played by Ian Holm that they’re actually accomplishing something. (They actually watch movies at their desks whenever he’s not looking.) It’s one of the most audaciously choreographed scenes in film history, and the movie throws it away in less than a minute. Or take another scene later in the film, when Lowry is assigned a dungeon of an office with only half a desk, the other half used by the worker in the next room; the insane tug of war the two have through the wall, over this one piece of furniture, is a gag Charlie Chaplin or Buster Keaton would have been proud to concoct.

An old love song called "Brazil" snakes in and out of all this, representing the longing for the happiness and transcendence that may or may not be accessible in a world gone so precipitously down the tubes. The film’s final position on this subject is complicated, to say the least. It’s a happy ending, of a sort ... and at the same time a heartbreakingly tragic one.

And therein lies the real rub. The history of film has been rife with masterpieces misunderstood by studios that did everything they possibly could to destroy them. That roll call of simultaneous honor and shame includes Erich Von Stroheim's silent classic Greed, cut from eight hours to just over 90 minutes, with the extra footage melted down for its silver content; Sergio Leone’s sprawling gangster epic Once Upon a Time in America, cut from four magnificent hours to an almost incoherent two; and, yes, Brazil, which became the subject of a major battle when the studio chief wanted to cut 40 minutes in a tasteless attempt to reduce this one-of-a-kind satiric nightmare to an action film with a more cliched form of happy ending. The director's cut played in theaters, and can be seen on home video.

The appalling studio version, which savaged almost everything that's remarkable about this film, still shows up occasionally on commercial television. Whatever you do, don't be fooled. One version is a flawed masterwork and one of the most remarkable films ever made. The other is an out-and-out abomination. -- Adam-Troy